Brilliant idea to turn subway turnstiles into music

NYC deserves as much beauty underground as it does topside, don't you think? Photo: ©2008 ANVidean

NYC deserves as much beauty underground as it does topside, don’t you think?
Photo: ©2008 ANVidean

Leave it to a musician to think of a way to make the New York subways more beautiful! Musician James Murphy suggests, in this video, how the city might replace the unpleasant turnstile notes that benefit sightless folk, with harmonic tones to please everyone. Tuned notes would chime as people pass through the turnstiles, making music instead of mismatched sounds. He also suggests a way that won’t cost the city additional monies.

Eric Whitacre answers audience questions at ASU, Oct. 24.  Photo: ©ANVidean 2013

Eric Whitacre answers audience questions at ASU, Oct. 24.
Photo: ©ANVidean 2013

Did I mention “brilliant?”

Thank you, composer Eric Whitacre for yet another wonderful share. You always demonstrate such exceptional ideas on how music can benefit our lives!

Seven words to encapsulate Eric Whitacre’s HIGHDEF music

Eric Whitacre answers audience questions at ASU, Oct. 24.  Photo: ©ANVidean 2013

Composer Eric Whitacre held an informal Q&A at Arizona State University, Oct. 24.   Photo: ©2013 ANVidean

My daughter Codi and I witnessed the brilliance of composer Eric Whitacre last night at Arizona State University. In Phoenix for a corporate speaking engagement, the fact that he offered to do a free, informal choral workshop and Q&A with the students and community, speaks volumes about this man’s quality.

Whitacre entered the Evelyn Smith Music Theatre to a standing ovation, and briefly critiqued one of his early compositions, “She Weeps Over Rahoon.“ The ASU Women’s Chorus performed the piece, under the direction of Ashley Conway, an ASU student earning her doctor of musical arts in music (conducting).

ASU Women's Choir workshop with Whitacre. Photo: ©ANVidean 2013

ASU Women’s Choir workshop with Whitacre.
Photo: ©2013 ANVidean

Participation in the charming, inspirational hour following the critique—as Whitacre answered audience questions—solidified my perception of this man as one of the musical geniuses of our time. Whitacre filled the room with humility, a huge sense of humor, and an indomitable talent.

I could share so much, but to avoid gushing even more, I narrowed my comments to fit into seven aspects of Eric Whitacre’s music using the applicable seven-letter acronym: HIGHDEF.


Whitacre’s work comes from a deep place of feeling, rather than a development of the craft. He said, at the urging of a Julliard professor, he tried to create music by learning the craft of music, but never could. He must follow inspiration gained from his feelings—sometimes delving him deep into the trenches of emotion—to bring forth the desired result.


Poetry serves as a grand inspiration for his work. He originally wrote one of his popular

pieces, “Sleep,” to accompany the words of a Robert Frost poem, “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening.” When he couldn’t get the poem’s rights, he asked his lyricist Charles Anthony Silvestri to help create new text to match the original poem’s exact cadence. You can hear the stunning result for yourself.

Whitacre described music as the gold gilt emphasizing certain poignant aspects of a poem —much like scribes, long ago, used gold highlights on passages in hand-copied books. He also described certain poems as vibrating so much with their own meaning, no music could possibly enhance them.

The composer also explained how he tried teaching, and other music jobs, but eventually recognized composition as the only job he felt inspired to really do well. He paid his dues: quit his job, immersed himself in writing music, and took every commission offered. The persistence paid off.


Most people know Whitacre because of his virtual choirs, which grew from an experiment into a cultural phenom. Thousands of people audition via video, and he compiles the recordings into a “virtual” composition using the submitted videos with added animation. The most recent, “Fly To Paradise,” released three months ago, involved 8,409 videos, and 5,905 singers in 101 countries. Whitacre’s next virtual choir, not yet announced, will involve middle-school-age youngsters.

His ideal work right now, he said, would involve working on collaborations with the likes of Radiohead, Byork, Peter Gabriel, movie score composer Thomas Newman, and others. Yessss!

He shared genuine answers to all audience questions, including how he met his wife, and his spiritual beliefs. Photo: ©2013 ANVidean

Whitacre shared genuine answers to all audience questions, including how he met his wife, and his spiritual beliefs. Photo: ©2013 ANVidean


A self-proclaimed agnostic, the composer said his music stems, rather than from divine inspiration, from the inspiration of humanity: love, anger, joy, children, and everything encompassing “human.”


The man is known for dissonance in his work, and also silence. One point he made in the workshop portion of the event, so impressed me. He talked to the singers about how to keep the music spinning through the musical rests. The choir responded to this abstract idea beautifully, and the audience could tangibly hear the “music” in the silence. Truly moving.


Most listeners cannot help but experience strong reactions inspired by Whitacre’s work. In my opinion, its intensity originates in the man’s personality. I can’t imagine meeting anyone with a more generous spirit, genuine spark for creativity, love for humanity, and non-stop sense of humor.


In his short workshop last night, he focused on specific and minute details, including the manner of directing, embodying the emotion behind the words and music, and even how using varying lengths when enunciating the letter “f” lend disparate emotions. The “before and after” flow and sound of his composition changed the piece completely, allowing the audience to hear Whitacre’s brilliant emotional intention.

I recommend, given any opportunity, make the effort to attend a talk or performance by Eric Whitacre. HIGHDEFinition quality indeed.